Chasing last year's top fund: why it so often disappoints
Recency bias makes recent winners look irresistible. Here's why a steadier approach usually serves investors better.

- Recent performance is the most visible number, and often the least useful on its own.
- Top-ranked funds in one period frequently don't stay on top in the next.
- Choose funds for their role in your plan, not their place in a league table.
The pull of the leaderboard
Every year, lists of the best-performing funds appear, and money flows into them. It feels logical: why not invest in what's working? The trouble is that last year's leader often owed its position to a particular style, sector or market phase that has already played out.
Studies of fund rankings over many years have repeatedly found that top performers in one period frequently fail to stay at the top in the next. Past performance genuinely does not guarantee future returns.
Recency bias, explained
Recency bias is our tendency to give recent events more weight than they deserve. In investing, it shows up as:
- Buying a sector fund after it has had a spectacular year
- Switching out of a sound fund after one weak year
- Assuming the current market mood will continue indefinitely
Frequent switching can also cost you: exit loads, capital gains tax on redemptions, and time out of the market between transactions.
A steadier way to judge a fund
| Instead of asking… | Ask… |
|---|---|
| What returned the most last year? | What role does this fund play in my plan? |
| Which fund is top of the rankings? | How has it done across a full market cycle, in rises and falls? |
| Should I switch to the winner? | Has anything changed about the fund's process, manager or mandate? |
| What's hot right now? | Does this fit my goal, timeline and comfort with risk? |
When a change does make sense
There are good reasons to change a fund: a change in its mandate or fund manager approach, a sustained period of underperformance against its own category and benchmark, or a change in your goals. These are reviewed calmly and periodically, not in response to a single year's ranking.
A thematic fund returned far more than everything else last year. What's the most sensible first question?
Nobody can know whether a return will repeat. What you can judge is whether the fund fits your plan.
This article is for general education only and is not investment, tax or legal advice. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks; read all scheme related documents carefully. Past performance does not guarantee future returns. Figures shown are illustrations that assume a constant rate of return and do not account for taxes, exit loads or expenses. Abhishek Marwah is an AMFI-registered Mutual Fund Distributor (ARN-41489).


